Pages

Saturday, August 2, 2008

Michael Poon responds to Rowan Williams

The other day I lauded Archbishop Rowan Williams' second presidential address. Michael Poon of Global South has responded with thoughtful criticism, especially of the binary description of the state of the Communion. Here's an excerpt but you can read the whole here:

"More seriously, this second Presidential Address showed a worrying misreading of the ground realities of the Communion. Together with many who come from churches outside the Anglo-American axis, I cannot identify myself with either side the Archbishop portrayed. It put me at a loss. What is the “generous initiative” am I supposed to take in the Communion? More poignantly, am I expected to take any generous initiative at all? Even more pointedly, has the Archbishop – with his best intents – completely ignored the realities outside the familiar Anglo-American perceptions? And so, the many generous acts of love from churches in the southern continents have been dismissed by the sense of “superiority and dependence” in the West, as Gregory Cameron has pointed out. This is to say, British academics and US financiers have the rest of the world all figured out and neatly configured from the vantage points of sanitised settings in the West."

No comments:

Post a Comment