Last week's post produced some deep discussion and fundamental disagreement among commenters.
One reflection from the past week's discussion - to my mind at least - concerns a basic truth/falsehood: God exists independently of human imagination and experience (or not).
That is, if God exists, independently of human existence, then a lot rests on those claims humans make about God, such as those made in the Old Testament and New Testament and subsequently through Christian history via testimony, doctrine, apologetics and liturgy. (Ditto, if, perchance, the existent God were the God attested to in, say, the Quran).
But if there is no God independently existent of human imagination and experience, then a number of things about human existence as spiritual beings would be a waste of time (such as spending time in prayer asking for help from and spending time in worship to a non-existent being). But other things could have a middling value, such as studying the Bible for some general wisdom about how to be a good and useful human being (compared to studying the Bible to know the will of a non-existent being).
If God exists beyond ourselves, as the Being from whom all existence flows (as, e.g., Judaism, Christianity and Islam claim), then we can reckon with possibilities such as miracles, including the Incarnation and the Resurrection. On this hypothesis, Geering likely is both wrong and currently aware that he is wrong. We might also reckon with possibilities such as God enacting judgment per biblical prophecy. Luther (for at least his treatment of the Jews) and Muntzer (for his failure to understand the loving, compassionate character of God) likely face a rather strict accountability encounter with the Judge of All.
If God does not exist beyond ourselves, then Geering (and thinkers like himself) are generally correct, we should pay attention to them, and give this life our best shot at living civilly (so society makes some kind of happy, sociable place to be). But I am with those last week who observed that there is also no particular reason not to live the life of, say, a drug dealer or drug user, gangster or Nazi or Stalinist. Whatever fills your boots, do it and see whether you get away with it in respect of human law and its enforcement. There is no need to worry about any other form of accountability for immoral behaviour.
More importantly, we really, really do need to determine, does God exist or not?
Such a basic and also such an important question.
As the writer to the Hebrews rightly observed in his great chapter on faith, "... for whoever would approach [God] must believe that he exists ..." (11:6).
Geering may turn out to be correct (but, ironically, some of us might never know if he is correct, because we may die believing he was wrong and have no life after death in which to appreciate that we were wrong and he was right!). I do not think we can prove that he has been incorrect. But there is much which points to the existence of God as the God beyond ourselves, the God whose existence is dependent on God's-self and not on ourselves.
Cue, in other words, all the arguments for and debates about the existence of God as the Being from whom all existence flows.
No comments:
Post a Comment