Wednesday, December 9, 2009

Ruth Gledhill's Interesting Assessment

Ruth Gledhill, as reported by herself, offers this assessment in the post-Glasspool election prognostications:

"My own view is that in terms of the leadership of the Church of England, the dreams of liberals, and the oppressed minorities they speak out in support of, are almost dead."

Her larger commentary can be found here. I do not have time to unpick her commentary which I think bears careful critique. But on the observation offered above I think she is on to something, something which is likely to be proven true in ACANZP. Putting it bluntly, in a declining church participation situation in the Western world, there are fewer and fewer liberals proportionately to vote in liberal leadership, offer and support liberal candidates for ministry, and to vote for liberal measures in synods. There are exceptions, TEC being the most obvious one (though even there it is worth looking carefully at how robust the liberal groupings are, though their proportionate strength increases with every conservative who leaves).

Or, am I quite wrong?

Kendall Harmon live Down Under

Now back from my lovely trip to Dunedin (an excellent academic conference, a performance of the Messiah, what's not to like ... ok, maybe the rain) to find that Kendall Harmon has been interviewed on Radio New Zealand. Sorry I missed the interview, Kendall!

The Titus One Nine link is here, and the MP3 recording can be found here.

Monday, December 7, 2009

Stand by your man

++Rowan Williams is getting stick via comments in response to reports of his published statement about Mary Douglas Glasspool's election to be a suffragan bishop in the Diocese of Los Angeles. Read them at the bottom of Ruth Gledhill's and Thinking Anglican's posts. Not much more positive in reception is to be found at Stand Firm. What did he say?

"Archbishop of Canterbury’s Statement on Los Angeles Episcopal Elections

Sunday 06 December 2009

The election of Mary Glasspool by the Diocese of Los Angeles as suffragan bishop elect raises very serious questions not just for the Episcopal Church and its place in the Anglican Communion, but for the Communion as a whole.

The process of selection however is only part complete. The election has to be confirmed, or could be rejected, by diocesan bishops and diocesan standing committees. That decision will have very important implications.

The bishops of the Communion have collectively acknowledged that a period of gracious restraint in respect of actions which are contrary to the mind of the Communion is necessary if our bonds of mutual affection are to hold."

A common theme in the comments on the first two sites mentioned above is 'The Archbishop has said nothing publicly against Uganda's death-to-gays legislation, but now he has the gall to rush to print the moment a lesbian is elected bishop in the USA.'

In this instance I want to stand by and with the Archbishop. With respect to Uganda we are told that he is working behind the scenes. Uganda is, after all, not under the Archbishop's jurisdiction; a foreign country; and a place with its own nuances about the best and most effective way to influence its political processes. Who is to say that the way of the Archbishop here is wrong? With respect to the affairs of the Anglican Communion, and the effects on those affairs of actions by member provinces, well, last time I looked, that is within the Archbishop's jurisdiction, at least to make comment.

All that can be said without examining what he actually says, which is pretty much a statement of facts: the election does raise serious questions around the Communion (for some Anglicans and perhaps some parishes it will be a 'last straw' with respect to remaining within the Communion), its confirmation will have serious implications (since, to give but one example, it will nail to the mast the true and effective interpretation of those resolutions passed at the GC 2009), and, if the bonds of affection are to hold, restraint is required. Stand firm on this matter, ++Rowan, and be not swayed by your critics!

Incidentally, to all those critics of the Covenant 'on the left', do the bonds of affection matter or not? We are constantly told that we do not need a Covenant, should not have a Covenant, etc; all because 'the bonds of affection' are enough to hold us together. This is not obviously true!

Shalom. Must away to a plane to a biblical studies conference in the land of Kiwi Scottishness (i.e. Dunedin).

Sunday, December 6, 2009

A whirlpool about Glasspool

Mary Douglas Glasspool has just been nominated as suffragan Bishop of Los Angeles. There will be a whirlpool about this nomination, both now, during the process of confirmation, and later, since, whether confirmed or not there will be controversy! Why? Mary is a same sex partnered woman. A report is http://www.episcopalchurch.org/79901_117538_ENG_HTM.htm.

Kendall Harmon has commented:

"This decision represents an intransigent embrace of a pattern of life Christians throughout history and the world have rejected as against biblical teaching. It will add further to the Episcopal Church's incoherent witness and chaotic common life, and it will continue to do damage to the Anglican Communion and her relationship with our ecumenical partners."

There are in fact some good things about this decision (assuming, for a moment, that confirmation will be granted). One good thing is that it gives a definitive interpretation on the mind of TEC as expressed at its recent General Convention: this church is not for turning from its resolve to admit no discrimination on any grounds between people inclined heterosexually and people inclined homosexually. Another good thing is that it invites the Communion to carefully consider that Gene Robinson's role as Bishop of New Hampshire within TEC is neither an aberration nor a temporary phenomenon (as in, with enough pressure he could be forced out). Partnered gay and lesbian bishops are here to stay.

The quick response (I guess) is: "Excommunicate TEC. Yesterday. Act quickly, ++Rowan." But there is another response; to think more slowly about whether we might be a Communion in which we have differing standards around clergy and singleness or marriage. This is a scary path because it means attempting to be a Communion united in a determination not to let difference over human dignity divide us. Why might we do this? Here are two reasons.

One, the people we are tempted to divide over are human beings. We may disagree furiously with their choices (e.g. to be in partnership, to offer for episcopacy). We may be aghast at the failure to secure agreement within the Communion on these matters. But that is part of being human: to not agree on all things. Do we walk away or keep talking, respecting who we are in the Lord?

Two, a formal schism in the Anglican Communion changes absolutely nothing about the fact that a bunch of people in the world's eyes call themselves Anglicans (or Episcopalians) and have a significant disagreement. It cuts no ice in mission to say, "We are the Anglicans without error. They are the Anglicans with error."

But this is not to imply that I think Los Angeles has been helpful to the Anglican Communion. It has not, for it is has placed local interest ahead of the global health of the Communion, as More than a Via Media points out. The goodness I see here is the goodness of clarity, not the goodness of shared conviction. The situation is not without possibility for remedial work on how we cope with it; but that is harder work than the situation where we walk together at the pace of the slowest members of the walking group.

Well, nothing said here will stop the whirlpool!

Saturday, December 5, 2009

Let's sort the Lectionary now before it gets out of hand

Bosco Peters has a brilliant post on the deficiency of the lectionary published for our church whereby it offers way too much choice. There are two points to a lectionary. One is that it is a guide to reading the Bible: presenting multiple choice is not a guide to reading the Bible, it is the presentation of an array of possible readings. Two is that the lectionary, especially in an Anglican context, should enhance the idea of 'common prayer'. Choice simply does not do that.

Bosco also draws attention to the disturbing trend of our lectionary to propose multiple colour alternatives for various days of the year. This should stop. The role of the lectionary at this point is to tell us what to do. We might choose to do something different, but if we choose to follow the lectionary (and be canonically obedient at the same time!) then we choose to be guided, and, incidentally, choose to walk in step with other parishes throughout the land and the world. Except that is not going to happen, except by luck, if we may use colour A, B, or C ... or even D!

Anyone else to join the campaign for lectionary reform?

I have not gone away!

Not much writing this week though plenty to say. I have been to
Christchurch twice within the week for a wedding, a funeral, a carol service and a prize-giving, with a trip to Westport in between. I intend to come back to my Gafcon book review, and to say something in support of a recent post by Bosco Peters on The Anglican Church of Or.

(from my iPod Touch which means the setting out may be awry)

Tuesday, December 1, 2009

Reading Scripture Wrightly to become a Scripture-formed Communion

Also from Journal of Anglican Studies Vol 7.2 (November 2009), a special issue on Lambeth 2008, is Bishop Tom Wright arguing passionately and picturesquely for Anglicans to engage more deeply, widely, and intensively in reading Scripture, privately and corporately. The article is entitled, "A Scripture-formed Communion? Possibilities and Prospects after Lambeth, ACC, and General Convention."

Not least in pressing this argument is the frustration Bishop Tom felt at the inadequacies of the Bible study material produced for Lambeth and at the low-levels of engagement on evidence in the Bible study groups. A significant point Bishop Tom argues repeatedly (that is, 'repeatedly' in the sense of a motif recurring through a great piece of music, not 'ad nauseam'!) is that too often too many Anglicans, on the right and the left, make superficial assumptions about the nature of ethics in the Bible, failing to reckon with 'the whole counsel of God' and with the character of the kingdom of God. Here is just one slice of Wrights rich fare [with his italics]:

"... the Bible itself demands to be read within a layered and nuanced hermeneutic. We cannot suppose that we can read any passage from the Old Testament and apply it 'directly' to ourselves; many parts come through with flying colours through the climactic and decisive events of Jesus' Kingdom-bringing life, death, and resurrection, and indeed with their emphases enhanced, but many other parts are left happily behind, their task complete. That, indeed, is what much of the letter to the Galatians is all about: the law had a temporary purpose, and when that purpose is accomplished those bits of the law can be wisely set aside, not as archaic or ill-informed rstrictive practices that we've now outgrown, but as necessary earlier elements in a plan which has now reached a new stage at which those elements, no longer required, are rightly to be shelved. The amphibious craft switches off the propeller when it comes on shore, not because the propeller was a bad thing we shouldn't have used in the first place but because it was a good thing which has completed its water-related job.

"All these reflections about new creation raise the question: how can we, within the church, teach one another to read Scripture with our eyes open to its deep and rich overall narrative, so that we can have the real debates that we should be having rather than the shallow ones we should have outgrown?" (pp. 172-73)

How, indeed!